Friday, 14 June 2013

NOTES FOR YEAR 11 ENGLISH HOMEWORK

Use the notes attached to help you to answer the question:  In what ways can the poem A Vision be interpreted and how?

Write for 45 minutes as a piece of exam practice.









Thursday, 28 February 2013

Sample Paragraph Year 10


HOW DOES STEINBECK PRESENT COMMUNITY IN ‘OF MICE AND MEN’?
The community of workers on the ranch are linked by geographical location and by economic situation; they are not linked by emotional bonds despite the fact that they live in a single room.  Steinbeck shows us that they are incapable of understanding tenderness or finer feelings but capable of salivating over the possibility of hunting down and killing one of their work mates.
Steinbeck presents the living conditions of the ranchmen as functional and plain; the floor of their accommodation is ‘unpainted’ as if there is little need to provide more comfort than is deemed strictly necessary (these are itinerant workers, after all, who stay in one place only for a short time, establishing little loyalty towards work mates or bosses and whose bosses would have little compunction about ‘can[ning]’ them if this were desirable).  The overriding impression given, then, is one of practicality both in terms of physical environment and in emotional responses.  Whilst the men may well have a tender side, this is not exposed to their companions; the magazines which they ‘scoff’ at, we are told they, ‘secretly believe’.  The ‘secretly’ is key here because it indicates a community where men feel ashamed of their dreams or romantic inclinations but where, deep inside them, these feelings do exist.  Perhaps this makes their treatment of the more vulnerable characters, Candy, Lennie, Crooks and Curley’s Wife, even more despicable; they become bullies, adopting a pack mentality, despite the fact that, should they seek it, they could establish an empathy with the weaker members of the community.
Circumstances on the ranch, however, the harshness of daily life, the adoption of the perhaps arguably natural tactic of survival of the fittest, mean that such empathy is lacking in all the men bar Slim.  The others have a skewed sense of justice and respect with Candy, for example, seeing the boss as a good man because he provided them with alcohol at Christmas and ignoring the fact that he gave Crooks ‘hell’ when George and Lennie did not arrive on time.  This treatment of a man socially, physically and, in this context, seen to be racially, inferior to him indicate the actions of a cruel man.  Certainly this is not a place with any sense of equality; a strict hierarchy exists and is ruthlessly applied.
Essentially Steinbeck presents us with a community which is racist, something evidenced by Whit’s appreciation of the fact that Susy, the brothel owner, ‘don’t let no goo-goos in’ and the fact that, even George, who we see as a much more rounded figure due to his capacity for love, does not question this casual racism.  It is also a community which places the practical above the emotional.  Carlson’s uncompromising determination to shoot Candy’s dog, a life- long companion, is based on an understanding of animal suffering; the dog is old and in pain and ‘ain’t no good to himself’; one might be tempted to see compassion in Carlson’s words here, were it not for the fact that he is incapable of understanding the deep emotional connection Candy has with his dog.  When Carlson returns to the bunk house after shooting the dog, he offers no words of comfort to Candy, he simply ‘fell to cleaning the barrel with the little rod; practical, not emotional considerations.
Steinbeck shows us a community which is far less than what a community should be.  There is a sense that the men are always looking for excitement, violence, and that they will see this as entertainment.  Whit, for example, seems thrilled at the prospect of hunting down Lennie; he speaks ‘excitedly’, bemoaning the fact that he ‘ain’t got a gun’ – instantly forgetting the man, Lennie, that he has worked with, seen being abused by, and then defeating, the common enemy, Curley,   and seeing only the opportunity to join in the hunt.  This is a place where animals are only animals and where men lack the subtlety and complexity to truly be men.